Throughout #GenderWeek, we’ve been asking our Members and readers to fill in our survey, responding to the question: What is gender?
We’ve had 148 responses, 36% of them from Feminist Times Members, and the remainder from readers and supporters who are not Members. The infographics below takes into account all 148 responses, while the examples of text responses selected from the responses of Feminist Times Members.
What is gender?
A selection of responses:
Gender is self defined. It is how you feel, what you associate with. Yes, there is a biological gender but that does not dictate the emotional gender of a person.
The state of being male or female (typically used with reference to social and cultural differences, rather than biological ones). I would use “sex” for the latter.
It refers to the structural relations between men and women, reflecting the dominance of men in society and the subordination of women.
For me it’s a biological definition. Sex you are physically born with.
Gender is the external representation of biological sex, the visible presentation of our sex as interpreted by society, a reductionist binary.
Whatever you identify with or what you aspire to identify with. However the spectrum can include many options and is not linked to sexuality.
Gender is the socially constructed roles, expectations and spaces to act allocated to biological men and women. Gender roles and entitlements are fluid across cultures and contexts, though are globally inequitable, with women allocated less status, fewer resources and very much restricted space and autonomy; in most cultures and contexts women are to a greater or lesser extent not understood or constructed as fully human, and often considered the property of men.
Gender, as it relates to the individual, is deeply personal and will affect each person differently. Gender does not exist in isolation, but is articulated in relation to other forms of repressions.
I believe gender is socially constructed; exists on a spectrum of performativity; not innate, but learned as part of sexual stereotyping during enculturation. One learns to perform binary oppositional ‘male’ and ‘female’. Sex determines XX, XY, and variations thereof.
Most people identify with the gender i.e. genitalia they were born to. But it must be incredibly painful for those individuals who do not fit into a specified gender, either because they are born with indeterminate genitalia or because they feel they are trapped in the wrong body. I believe those individuals should have the right to choose the identity they feel comfortable with.
A hierarchical oppressive social construct designed to keep women at the bottom of the hierarchy.
It is the biological differences between human beings, defined by reproductive function. It is the cultural differences between human beings that have come about by the unequal distribution of power and education.
Ideally it’s a personal identity but the lived reality is that others place their opinions of your gender over what you say and treat you according to how they believe people of your gender should be treated. I think there is some overlap between liberal and radical ideas behind gender in that both believe you can suffer because of your gender, but modern feminism recognises that there is more than just gender at play in the systems of oppression that we all live under.
A social construct – I agree with Simone de Beauvoir when she said that women aren’t born, they are created.
How do you define your own gender?
A selection of responses:
Female, woman, cis, trans, queer, gender-queer, agender, anti-gender, gender-free, gender-fluid, gender-variant, non-binary, cisgender, cis-woman, transman, transwoman, lesbian-feminist, transfeminine, masculine, femme, man, queer-femme, unspecified, non-gendered, conformist, rebellious, spectrum.
What defines your gender?
Your sex strongly influences your perception of your gender because people with female genitals are defined in certain ways.
Not necessarily, it depends a lot on background and upbringing so for me yes, but I don’t think that it has to for anyone!
Genitals define your sex, which is often incorrectly used intechangiby with gender.
I’m born intersex and I try to reject gender classifications, while acknowledging that a third classification doesn’t solve the gender hierarchy or anything very much, in and of itself.
No, but they are used by cultural norms to construct a gender identity.
They contribute to my being assigned into the sex class.
Would prefer them to be different – they don’t define me.
I don’t know, probably because I identify with the same gender that my genital identify me as and I was brought up in that gender. I can’t tell whether they are defining it or not.
They do if you view it as a binary, but if we were to see gender as traits, social conditioning and assumptions not as something essential, then no, they don’t at all.
My genes (probably) coincide with my chromosomal gender.
They determine biological sex.
Mix of genes and socialisation.
I don’t know. They likely have an influence.
No, but my genetic makeup as a female determines what gender society considers appropriate for me.
Scientifically yes but I’m not 100% sure.
Not define but will nurture a direction.
None of us are outside our socialised experience. I would say that I am not a ‘woman’ in the sense that my culture and socialisation has taught me I should be – however, at the same time, my understanding of myself as a woman has been and continues to be in reference to that as i unlearn some expectations, reshape my understanding and do not live outside social discourses of womanhood. I am constantly engaged in struggle between my definitions and those of the people around me.
To some extent, but you can resist.
‘Socialisation’ is how one comes about having an understanding of one’s gender – indeed the only understandings any of us have of any human concept come to use through social relations, as otherwise how would we know what we mean by something is the same as what others mean by it? Furthermore as one aspect to gender is its force of compulsory normativity, for many people their understanding of their gender will one envisaged as to be in accordance with this normative force, which could be what some consider the term ‘socialisation’ to mean. However one’s gender identity itself is constituted as an *engagement* with the set of power relations (e.g. norms etc.) that make up gender, which in each person is always in tension, never perfect accordance, with the elusive ideal of ‘woman’ (or ‘man’) posited by social relations.
No, but it created my concepts of gender.
Yes, but socialization is a complex process that can produce a variety of understandings of gender norms, gender identity, and one’s “place” relative to gender, so saying that trans women experience some kind of homogenous “male socialization” is simplistic and locates systems of oppression in the individual, not in the class (woman) which includes everyone who experiences societal messages about women in the first person, regardless of whether they’re “Supposed” to do so.
No, but it does contribute to one’s experiences and personal history, which are important.
Which of these statements do you agree with?
Top 5 responses:
- Gender is a social construct (19%)
- A rigid gender binary oppresses both men and women who don’t conform (19%)
- Sex is biological (17%)
- Gender is a personal identity (14%)
- My vision of the future is a spectrum of gender (14%)
Do you identify as…?
How sure are you that you have XX chromosomes as a woman and XY chromosomes as a man?
(1) being Not at all sure and (5) being So sure I’d bet my life on it.
Word clouds created via Wordle
We are 100% crowdfunded, with no advertising, so we only survive if people join as Members or donate. If you enjoyed this article and want to support this site, become a member by clicking the badge below…
Or donate a one off amount…